What is the Prison Litigation Reform Act?

The Prison Litigation Reform Act (PLRA) is a U.S. federal law enacted in 1996 with the primary aim of reducing the number of frivolous lawsuits filed by prisoners. The act was introduced as part of a broader effort to address perceived abuses in the legal system by inmates, who often filed numerous, sometimes groundless, lawsuits. Here are some key provisions of the PLRA:

1. Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies: Prisoners must exhaust all available administrative grievance procedures within the prison system before they can file a lawsuit in federal court. This means they must follow and complete the prison’s internal complaint process.
2. Filing Fees: The PLRA requires inmates to pay filing fees for lawsuits and appeals, although they can pay these fees over time if they are unable to pay the full amount upfront. This is intended to deter inmates from filing frivolous lawsuits simply because they have nothing to lose financially.
3. Three Strikes Rule: If a prisoner files three or more lawsuits that are dismissed as frivolous, malicious, or for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, the inmate is barred from filing additional lawsuits without prepaying the full filing fee, unless they are under imminent danger of serious physical injury.
4. Physical Injury Requirement: The PLRA requires that inmates prove physical injury in order to claim damages for mental or emotional harm. This limits the ability of inmates to seek compensation for non-physical injuries.
5. Limitations on Attorneys' Fees: The act restricts the amount of attorneys' fees that can be awarded in prisoner rights cases, making it less financially attractive for attorneys to represent prisoners in civil rights cases.
6. Judicial Review: The PLRA gives federal courts more authority to terminate existing court orders and consent decrees for prison reform if the court finds that the conditions have been corrected and the orders are no longer necessary.

The PLRA has been controversial since its enactment. Supporters argue that it has successfully curbed frivolous litigation and reduced the burden on the federal court system. Critics, however, contend that it has made it significantly more difficult for prisoners to seek justice for legitimate grievances and has hindered efforts to address serious issues within the prison system.

Contact The Justice Law Firm, LLC today for a FREE consultation.